How to Sell Pet Toys on Etsy and Boost Your Sales

Find more profitable niche ideas with Niche Deep Dive Kits!

If you’re a maker of handmade pet toys, Etsy is hands down one of the best platforms to sell your products. Why? It’s simple. Etsy is a marketplace that’s built around craftsmanship, creativity, and the unique nature of handmade goods—just like your pet toys. Whether you’re crafting eco-friendly chew toys for dogs or custom catnip mice for cats, Etsy’s audience is already primed to appreciate and purchase the kinds of one-of-a-kind, thoughtful items that you’re making.

Let’s dive into why Etsy is such a great place to sell your handmade pet toys and what sets it apart from other e-commerce platforms.

A Marketplace That Values Handmade

Unlike large e-commerce platforms like Amazon or eBay, Etsy is specifically designed for people who value craftsmanship and creativity. It’s a space where buyers expect—and actively seek out—unique, handmade, and personalized products. If you’ve spent time carefully designing and crafting your pet toys, Etsy’s audience is going to appreciate your effort and the quality of your work.

For buyers on Etsy, there’s an intrinsic value placed on buying from independent creators and small businesses. People who shop on Etsy are not just looking for a generic toy they can get anywhere—they want something that feels special, that’s made with care, and that often reflects a higher level of quality and uniqueness. This means that, unlike other platforms where you might feel pressure to compete with mass-produced items, Etsy allows you to price your products in a way that reflects the time, effort, and materials that go into creating them.

Tapping Into the Growing Pet Market

The pet industry is booming. According to market research, the global pet care market is projected to reach over $269 billion by 2025. People love their pets and are willing to spend money on products that make their furry friends happy, especially when those products are handmade, eco-friendly, and customizable. Whether it’s toys, accessories, or personalized items, pet owners are looking for products that cater to their pets’ individual needs and personalities.

Etsy allows you to tap into this growing market. With an ever-increasing number of pet owners shopping online for high-quality pet products, you have a prime opportunity to offer your handmade toys to a global audience. Plus, Etsy’s search algorithm and filters allow pet owners to find exactly what they’re looking for—whether it’s a durable chew toy, a soft plush toy, or a completely customized creation with their pet’s name on it.

Benefits of Selling Pet Toys on Etsy

One of the best things about Etsy is that it allows creators to reach a global audience. You’re not limited to selling locally or even nationally—Etsy connects you with buyers from around the world. This gives you the opportunity to showcase your pet toys to a wider range of customers who appreciate handmade, quality goods.

Additionally, Etsy’s low barrier to entry makes it accessible for new sellers. Setting up your shop is easy and inexpensive, and you won’t need a huge upfront investment to get started. This is perfect for small businesses or individuals who are just dipping their toes into selling online.

Moreover, Etsy’s built-in marketing tools help you promote your products with minimal effort. From Etsy Ads to social media integration, you have multiple ways to get your handmade pet toys in front of potential buyers without needing a complicated marketing plan.

Crafting High-Quality, Appealing Pet Toys

When it comes to selling handmade pet toys on Etsy, your products need to stand out. The great news is, if you’re already putting time and care into crafting these toys, you’re halfway there. But what really makes a pet toy not only eye-catching but also practical? It’s a combination of quality materials, pet-safe designs, and, of course, creating toys that are as fun for pets as they are appealing to pet owners.

Let’s explore the essential elements of crafting pet toys that will make your Etsy shop a go-to destination for pet lovers.

Materials and Safety Considerations

One of the biggest priorities when crafting pet toys is safety. Pets, especially dogs and cats, are notorious for chewing, gnawing, and clawing their toys to pieces. This means your toys need to be durable and safe. When selecting materials, always go for pet-safe, non-toxic options. For example, if you’re making chew toys, natural fibers like organic cotton or hemp are ideal. These materials are strong, environmentally friendly, and, most importantly, safe for pets to chew on.

Avoid materials that could pose a choking hazard or break apart too easily. For instance, small beads, plastic eyes, or buttons could easily be swallowed by pets, leading to dangerous situations. Instead, opt for embroidered details or seamless designs that reduce the risk of parts breaking off. The durability of the materials you choose directly impacts how much trust pet owners will have in your product.

For cats, the use of natural fillers like organic catnip can be a big selling point. Catnip toys are a huge hit, but the key is using high-quality, safe catnip that’s free from pesticides and chemicals. This appeals not just to pets, but to health-conscious pet owners as well.

Designing for Fun and Functionality

The best pet toys aren’t just durable; they’re also fun! After all, the goal is to keep pets entertained while also providing enrichment. Different pets have different needs, so it’s essential to offer a variety of toys that cater to those needs. For example:

Chew Toys for Dogs: Dogs love to chew, and chew toys that are tough, textured, and easy to grip are always a hit. If you can incorporate natural rubber or durable fabrics into your design, your toys will last longer and provide hours of fun.
Interactive Toys for Cats: Cats love to hunt, bat, and chase, so toys that mimic this behavior—like feather wands or rolling toys—will capture their attention. Interactive toys, especially those infused with catnip, are highly popular.
Puzzle Toys for Both Dogs and Cats: Puzzle toys that challenge pets to work for their treats or rewards add an extra layer of mental stimulation, keeping them engaged for longer periods.

When designing your toys, think about their durability, but also think about what makes them engaging. Ask yourself, “Would this toy hold up to a playful puppy, or would it be irresistible to a curious cat?”

Personalization and Customization

One way to stand out in the crowded Etsy marketplace is to offer personalized or customized pet toys. Pet owners love unique, one-of-a-kind items, especially when they can add a personal touch. Consider offering customizations like:

Personalized Names: Embroider the pet’s name onto the toy to create a special connection between the owner and the toy.
Custom Colors or Patterns: Allow customers to choose the colors or patterns that best suit their pet’s personality or match their home decor.
Made-to-Order Toys: Create toys based on customer requests, such as specific materials for pets with allergies or preferences.

Offering personalized touches helps make your shop memorable and gives customers the chance to buy something truly special for their pets.

Setting Up Your Etsy Shop for Success

Once you’ve crafted your amazing handmade pet toys, it’s time to showcase them in an Etsy shop that captures the attention of pet owners. A successful Etsy shop requires more than just great products—you need a professional-looking storefront, clear product descriptions, and eye-catching photos to stand out in a competitive marketplace.

Here’s how to set up your shop for success:

Creating an Attractive Etsy Shop

Your shop’s visual appeal is crucial for making a great first impression. Make sure your shop reflects the creativity and quality of your handmade pet toys.

Shop Name: Choose a memorable name that reflects your brand and products (e.g., “Pawfect Pet Toys”).
Shop Banner & Logo: Create a professional-looking banner and logo that visually represent your shop. You can design these yourself or use platforms like Canva.
About Section: Share your story. Pet owners love to support small businesses, so let them know why you make your toys and what makes them special.

Writing Detailed Product Descriptions

Clear, informative product descriptions help buyers understand what makes your toys unique and why they should buy from you.

Materials: List all the materials used, emphasizing pet-safe and eco-friendly options.
Size & Dimensions: Clearly state the size of each toy to help customers choose the right fit for their pet.
Benefits: Explain the benefits of your toy, such as durability or how it keeps pets entertained.

Photography Tips for Pet Toys

High-quality photos are key to catching the eye of potential buyers.

Multiple Angles: Show the toy from various angles and in different settings.
Lifestyle Images: Include photos of pets playing with the toys to help buyers imagine the product in use.
Close-Ups: Highlight important details like textures, colors, or personalization options.

By following these steps, your Etsy shop will be ready to attract customers and drive sales.